What does being "big" have to do with it?
I'm getting tired of hearing this kind of thing lately. I get that I'm considered "big" by most measures. I also get that I'm "pretty", or at least that's what I've been told a few times. I don't understand what the two have to do with each other. I have never in my life heard someone say to another person, "You are so pretty for a skinny/thin/small girl!" It's almost if by virtue of being thin, a person is automatically attractive. I do think that everyone possesses a beauty all their own, sometimes it's on the inside, and sometimes it's on the outside, sometimes it's both. BUT, I'm kind of tired of feeling like some sort of anomaly because my weight somehow doesn't match my level of attractiveness. Or prettiness. Or whatever.
(Image from http://www.beautifulyoubyjulie.com/)
Honestly, I've never been a person that looks in the mirror and thinks that a pretty face is what seals the deal. I think of myself as more of a person that is fun, happy (most days), exciting, adventurous, spontaneous, has depth, etc. I guess I have always thought of my personality or inner beauty to be my measure of attraction. Yeah, I like to have my makeup done just right, or my hair to work with me, and my clothes to look like I haven't just rolled out of bed nice. I'm just trying to figure out when my "prettiness" started being directly correlated to how much weight I carry. I have been a thin (NOT skinny) girl, I have been an athlete, and I have been fat; I've been everywhere in between. Never once when I was thin or athletic did anyone ever say to me, "You are so pretty for an athlete!" Should they have said it that way? Did it matter since I was "thin"? See what I'm saying?
I think in a culture where we have this strange dichotomy of 1) being obsessed with weight, and 2) encouraging self-love regardless of the number on the scale, we still put the focus on the amount of body fat a person has. Really, I can be ugly. You should see me at 5pm after a day of cleaning, having both kids at home all day, my face broken out all to hell, still in my pajamas, and having forgotten to brush my teeth or wash my face. It's NOT pretty! And regardless of whether I've dressed for a night on the town or I'm looking like dog squeeze, I'm still fat. What I'm trying to say, or ask rather, is why my weight has to have something to do with it? Attraction/prettiness is really rather subjective anyway, yes? I'm sure there are people out there who would LOVE to be my size, whether they are thin or fat right now. And I'm sure there are people out there who think I'm absolutely disgusting. WHO CARES?! Or more importantly, do I really care that you think my weight and prettiness have some sort of relation to each other? And is it even your business to share that with me? It's confusing.
All I'm really hoping is that before you compliment someone, or comment on their attractiveness/prettiness, think about how you say it or if it is even necessary to say. If someone is pretty to you, forget trying to "help" them by validating their weight as part of the comment. Because this, "You are so pretty for a big girl," really just sounds like this, "Even though you are fat, you are still pretty." And this, "He must really like big girls," sounds like, "He must really like fat girls." Not even a mention of "pretty" in that one! For someone dealing with weight-related issues, or trying to lose weight, or whatever, it's hurtful and unnecessary. Please just say, "You are pretty." Or, "He must think you are beautiful." The prettiness of you or me is not related to the size of our body. It's related to what someone else thinks beauty may be, and why. And it really is NOT necessary to point out someone's body size/shape. We all know that we are skinny or fat or somewhere in between.
I'm just having a bit of a moment because I feel like I've heard this so much lately from multiple people, and I'm about to start throwing out typical Dana-style smartass comments, and I'm trying to avoid that. And just to give credit where credit is due, I think the ONLY person in my life who has never led me to believe that my attractiveness is correlated to my weight is my incredible husband. And I'm thankful to have a person in my life (who plays such an important role) who has managed to leave that one alone. I love you, Gid!